(Q507)
Statements
Yes, I would like to do my review and voting 1 day a week.
0 references
These assets are great for command-based animation, not just for creating indy games (which can be easily made with tools like RPG maker and Chat GPT). Command-based animation can be used to make all sorts of UGC outside of gaming as well, such as digital shorts. I think this could be a useful tool in proliferating Nouns.
0 references
A great call to action for nouners and builders in our eco-system to authentically onboard others in a nounish way--the real reward will not be the prize we offer but those we bring in to build with us--that is nounish--Lets put the FUN in Funding.
0 references
I like cartoons, I make cartoons, and I like others making cartoons--great team, cant wait for this one to go! Square rims animated look neat-o!
0 references
I know this is not everyones bag--but having worked on shows at adult-swim I know there is an audience for this and could be impactful.
0 references
To the Nouners out there that vote and Nouncil–this is the type of signal that cuts through the noise. Since the disbanding of the main discord I spend a lot of time running through all the discords and all over Twitter to collect information that is of use to me–What Maty does is help filter out the things I am less interested in and helps me find what ultimately matters most to me and what I need to perform as a member of the DAO. If you don’t already subscribe to his newsletter you should, and I think as a DAO we should fund this as a core contribution as it serves the members and supports the ecosystem.
0 references
When asked what he thought Nounish meant 4156 said do good with no expectation of return, create positive externalities, embrace absurdity & difference, teach people about nouns & crypto, have fun We hope all of you think this is a Nounish Proposal
0 references
Although we have reservations on how were tracking success on this prop (and any IRL prop in general), were excited to support Stoopid Buddy and Nouns IRL efforts. Going forward, we would like to see more data-driven elements such as QR codes or other traditional IRL tools used to measure results. Nothing measured is nothing gained.
0 references
As the discord is dissolved the DAO should help create more tools such as videos that the different communities can use to hype, educate, and inspire others to come and join us. With the success of their video in Times Square, and proving it out on their own dime, I feel like we should support them if we think that was a success. I also have faith in this team being able to deliver what they promise.
0 references
Based on the feedback we received from the DEVCon event in Bogota sounded great and I cant wait to see the results in AU. Oxigami has a great reputation and a track record of getting things done to proliferate the meme, I am excited to see what he and his team can do here. I think these regional OTG activations with local builders are one of the pillars of growing Nouns as an authentic brand.
0 references
I believe Nouncil has been an important part of Nouns DAO and we should continue to support their efforts in proliferating the meme. Funding builders that have a proven track record to help us grow is a good thing.
0 references
I am a hell yes for these types of Proposals. As someone who did the convention circuit for years, I know these displays can really make a long-term impression on attendees. I also think they are one of the most impactful OTG initiatives we can do.
0 references
As we move from one discord to many discords and this has added time to hunt down and discuss the proposals extending the time for props to go on-chain and get voted on makes more sense. This also may alleviate future pressure points if we have an influx of on-chain proposals that need review before we vote on them. I am happy to support this proposal.
0 references
I feel like any Nouner should be able to propose to the rest of the protocol their idea on-chain and let the other nouners or delegates vote for or against it. If Nouners don’t want to give the proposals attention that is their business as they have deployed capital into it. Just having immediate access to one noun does not signal a bad idea, we can look at past proposals and see that is not the case. Drop the threshold, invite ideas, and good ideas will rise to the top.
0 references
As a person that uses Ai every day for work, I think the DAOs involvement with machine learning, in general, is important. I also think the tools that this pod will develop will help many proliferate the meme.
0 references
I think the work CDT does for the DAO is important and we should continue to fund him for this next period.
0 references
I think this is an important step for the future of this project and others in governance.
0 references
Creating this type of shareable content is a great tool to help with proliferation, however, we need to remember that they are a help. We need to support these types of projects not just with our votes but actions by sharing and helping distribute their videos across our socials.
0 references
With these 2 things combined this seems like a great way to create sharable content. Nouns artwork by Brazilian artists will be painted at the Skate Cuida Institute, where classes are taught by Bob Burnquist. + We will bring a film crew and later deliver a clip registering the workshops and painting action.
0 references
Based on the feedback we have heard thus far it is currently not a hell yes from us at this time. If this does not pass we want to encourage Aubtoshi to rework and resubmit based on the feedback. If this does pass we wish Aubtoshi the best in her endeavors.
0 references
I am chatting with 0xigami as I am writing this--he knows how I am voting. We both have the skater mindset. bail. get back up. dust off. climb stairs. -Gami And thats how he proliferates just like a vert skater, Go ALL in or FALL in, dont leave one foot on the coping -Sam Ellis I have been excited to see the highest voter turnout for this prop. I encourage him and the Gnars DAO to revise and resubmit, if this prop does not pass, based on some of the feedback that has been given by the DAO I say some as I consider Gami an expert in his field. If resubmitted by just GNARS sans Gami, please see the above comment. Gami, Gnars--I love you crazy builders Oh, and Bob Burnquist--stick around I promise it will be worth it.
0 references
I want to encourage the team to rework and resubmit based on the feedback.
0 references
I want to encourage the team to rework and resubmit based on the feedback.
0 references
I like the idea of the imagery, but not a hell yes in its current form. I am sure this will pass, but I would like to see what kind of activation efforts could be built into this and then resubmitted.
0 references
Though I am a big fan of the NNS in general and am proud to be part of the first extensions to resolve the .⌐◨-◨ on yolonouns.wtf, nounstown.wtf, and puppetsamurai.wtf I am not sure there is enough traction at this point to give it the hell yes from me. If this prop does not pass I hope DOM makes some revisions and brings this back on-chain with a bit more focus on adoption, both with users and resolvers. I also think we should have some retro reward for all of his efforts over the past 7 months.
0 references
We are big fans of Builder and Zora, but we would love to see some traction or more details on how they would deploy the capital (criteria, vetting, etc). We would encourage the team to provide more details and/or lower their initial ask with the intention to return for a larger ask once there is demonstrable traction in the market.
0 references
I am a huge fan of the Nouns News, however, for what is being made currently it seems the team is a bit bloated and the price seems to reflect that. I also am not sure if 1M is that great of a metric on TikTok, with the TikTok creator fund when you hit 1M views as a creator you can make $20-$40, if the platform puts that low a price of value on those views why would we spend so much? If the TikToks were more interactive and had more calls to action I may be in favor. I encourage you to revisit this if the prop does not pass.
0 references
Though I am a fan of this type of action in general, I want more than just a top-funnel activity. What does success look like for this, how do we measure impact, would this be better during an event? Could this be bigger? With the desired outcomes being squishy I will have to vote no at the current time but would encourage you to revisit and resubmit with some rework to your prop to help me say, hell yes. Nothing measured is nothing gained.
0 references
While I am a big fan of Agora, the following factors lead me to vote NO on this prop in its current state. 1) Lack of platform traction, 2) Outsized ask, 3) Lack of prop specificity. I would vote YES on an Agora prop that could either demonstrate more traction or have more specifics as to prop deliverables. Also, clarity on the goals as related on the Nouncil call today, of double participation and delegation. Does that mean votes or wallets? I really want to support this but I would like a bit more clarity.
0 references
I support artists and participated in the Noundry submissions but do not think this prop is ready in its current state.
0 references
Im currently uncertain about the business strategy behind this proposal... Its challenging to see how it can evolve into a self-sustaining venture without a more comprehensive plan. Right now, it almost feels like a concealed levy intertwined with other proposals, with their success uncertain. Id prefer to see a proposal that directly supports you in establishing this as an independently viable business or considers funding the LO-FI Noggles as a public good/utility, thereby enabling everyone to access the designs and production capabilities as needed. Otherwise, when is the next request, or the next one, or the next one... Its absolutely fine to request that event organizers contribute towards the cost of these novel additions to their events. A little friction can sometimes be necessary and there are instances when its best to eliminate the intermediary, similar to Ethereum. Recently Ive observed piles of unused stickers from events which left me hesitant for this one, yes even noggle stickers that were not just handed out by randos to randos. I truly appreciate the LO-FI Noggles and am delighted to see them at a lower production cost, but with what I have seen unused and thrown away from similar items I feel so much apprehension to be a straight hell yeah on this. I want to reiterate, I would be very much interested in a prop that funded you and nounworks as a viable business that becomes self-sufficient in its operations.
0 references
Reason (Optional) However Re: Noun12 Before spending $100k+ on a platform, need to see evidence that the strategy the platform is being built for has demand. Prove out more, ask for funding after having proof of potential or PMF.
0 references
I am supportive of these types of projects but voiced my concerns in a nouns community discord that when doing edutainment (educational entertainment) accuracy of the content is essential.
0 references
Due to the cc0 nature of NounsDAO IP, Pudgy Penguins could move forward without the DAOs approval but we want this to be an official collaboration, bringing the Huddle into the Nouns ecosystem. If you want to engage--just engage.
0 references
I fully support this proposal and would like to see it pass but am abstaining as I sponsored this prop on-chain.
0 references
Initiatives like NSFW are important to be able to help motivate and incentivize builders in our ecosystem. I do however agree with the Nounders that it needs to be more decentralized with multiple voices. This does not mean that anyone has done a bad job. However, moving NSFW into a more decentralized pod with more participants that are anxiously engaged in voicing their opinions and impacting outcomes has a great deal of merit, this will also support 22 in his efforts so that all of the burdens dont fall solely on his shoulders as it is a lot of work liaising with all of the different requests. I am not voting against this proposal, because I know of all the good that can come out of this program for both the receivers of the rewards and the DAO, however, I would be a hell yes if this was a proposal that also included a full-time group/POD working on NSFW, sharing their knowledge, streamlining the process, coming up with more standardized rewards, and having the rewards/outcomes be more publicized across social media.
0 references