Proposal 328 (Q5662)

From Nouns Dev
A Nouns proposal.
Language Label Description Also known as
English
Proposal 328
A Nouns proposal.

    Statements

    0 references
    107
    0 references
    328
    0 references
    0 references
    0 references
    In April 2022, the Nouns DAO commissioned Brooklyn-based artist Dustin Yellin to create a new sculptural portrait, PERSON, PLACE, or THING. The artwork integr ates the 402 Nouns minted in Year One into a unique glass piece.
    0 references
    10,000,000
    0 references
    Dustin yellin studio
    0 references
    8 July 2023
    0 references
    NAC to Pay Dustin Yellin & Return Remaining ETH to Treasury
    0 references
    50
    0 references
    0
    0 references
    193
    0 references
    115
    0 references
    0 references
    1
    0 references
    Very much in favor of 1. We do what we say we will do. 2 and 3 should be separate proposals. NAC shouldnt be paying Dustin ETH, its not why it exists.
    0 references
    Agree with requests to write a more clear prop.
    0 references
    reVoteWithReason from wilsoncusack.eth > This proposal is very confusing and should be cancelled and resubmitted as multiple proposals. 1. Mandate NAC send Noun 252 to Dustin Yellin Studio 2. Request DAO send 50 ETH to Dustin Yellin Studio (NAC does not exist as some fallback protection for proposers to get promised funds from DAO) 3. Dissolve NAC (? That seems to be the subtext here, but its not clear.) *sent from voter.wtf* *sent from voter.wtf*
    0 references
    This proposal is very confusing and should be cancelled and resubmitted as multiple proposals. 1. Mandate NAC send Noun 252 to Dustin Yellin Studio 2. Request DAO send 50 ETH to Dustin Yellin Studio (NAC does not exist as some fallback protection for proposers to get promised funds from DAO) 3. Dissolve NAC (? That seems to be the subtext here, but its not clear.) *sent from voter.wtf*
    0 references
    reVoteWithReason from max-power.eth > cuz its awesome *sent from voter.wtf*
    0 references
    Voting yes because, on principle, the DAO should follow through on its offchain commitments that it makes to contributors who fulfill the conditions for those commitments. And I think the actual sculpture that Dustin Yellin made was fantastic and he deserves to be compensated accordingly! *sent from voter.wtf*
    0 references
    0 references
    **FOR - 37 VOTES** **AGAINST - 4 VOTES** **eltonpenguin** | *I prefer 327* **supertightwoody** | *Need more clarity in this proposal. Im not sure how/why everyone is voting yes for this when its extremely unclear what the tx and final deliverables are.* **ABSTAINS - 6 VOTES** *sent from voter.wtf*
    0 references
    Voting yes out of principle. As a DAO, we must honor our previous commitments or else a lot of what Nouns fundamentally stands for around proliferation and paying it forward breaks down.
    0 references