0x91dccaa260cc4616e1a6e6b693db7207c5e42937 (Q202)
From Nouns Dev
Individual
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | 0x91dccaa260cc4616e1a6e6b693db7207c5e42937 |
Individual |
Statements
i am for more flexible payment options but support taking more time + audits based on soli & cos feedback
0 references
love to see v2 props going back onchain incorporating feedback. proposers seem uniquely positioned to execute on their vision and the additional focus on marketing & distribution provides high conviction in getting the nouns brand+art in the eyes/hands of a ton of new people
0 references
+1 to 40s, ccarellas, and salvinos comments discussed on weekly Q&A call ensuring nouns IP representation beyond optional phone variant and team was receptive
0 references
agree with the points made in the why section of the proposal, also agree with willpapper that reaching out to gitcoin ahead of time might have provided additional marketing/PR opportunities (perhaps retro opp will be available if prop is successful)
0 references
feels a little expensive but more importantly feels very nounish
0 references
excited to see new artists bringing their talents (and new mediums) into the ecosystem
0 references
i hope the team will come back with a bit more details on the design & distribution side to increase confidence in this experiment
0 references
while this is a large ask, nouns esports has executed at a high level making a major impact in the gaming community in a short period of time. im optimistic that well be able to find additional on-brand sponsors to help subsidize the ongoing costs of running the team ahead of future proposals
0 references
i dont think influencer raffles & giveaways are nounish but am hoping to see other activations/initiatives scale up with these tools
0 references
ambitious prop with a lot of moving parts but large opportunity in an untapped market, spoke with the team and feel good about taking the risk for potential outsized returns
0 references
no mention of converting funds to USDC upon transfer, just something for team to consider
0 references
public goods x proliferation = bucketsss ⌐◨-◨ strong support for building this type of marketing infrastructure that will be around for years to come
0 references
tapping into the deeper art scene which could pay unknown dividends down the line
0 references
can always vote to adjust again if things really start bussin
0 references
fiveoceans has made a number of creative contributions to the community, happy to see one their projects on-chain. reading through the cost breakdown, i didnt see any sort of compensation for project management/oversight. if this proposal passes, i would support small grants funding to provide compensation for fiveoceans or whoever is coordinating this effort
0 references
excited to see more compelling interpretation projects!
0 references
we like the nouncil. excited to see what comes out of this proposal
0 references
curated short video content feels like an area of opportunity this prop empowers dedicated community members to create CC0 video of proposals that might not otherwise generate such content
0 references
wag has contributed an immense amount of time and brainpower towards ensuring the dao is maximally nounish. i support this pilot and am excited to see the nouncillors engaged as well.
0 references
best to approve this so we can keep a close eye on him, this new-found fame is going to his head
0 references
appreciate the efforts from this team but dont have high conviction in ROI/success on the proposal in current state it is already hard enough to build a fun & compelling gameplay loop without integrating an educational aspect and this product would be competing with best in class for products for users entertainment time some concerns with monetization plans, in-game currency / microtransaction strategies are not detailed and if done wrong can provide a poor experience for new users first exposure to nouns coming in via paid ads. pay to play power ups can impact competitive integrity and i dont expect users to pay for anything that only enhances the single player experience. gamers have specific expectations + high quality bar in mind when a product offers a Battle Pass and having new game modes behind a pay wall doesnt seem appropriate for a new ip/indie product trying to break into the space no mention of AI, is it AI available in multiplayer? without reaching critical mass in multiple regions I would assume that there wont be a constant stream of players to fill out 40 person matches
0 references
current engagement #s doesnt seem to indicate product market fit (yet), may need a smaller/scaled down prop or additional engagement on current site to justify
0 references
i like the idea of this proposal but concerned around the costs/DAO ROI and demand for this # of nounish keyboards @ the high end designer price point, also unsure about the DAO aspect
0 references
large ask while the primary use case(s) dont feel particularly compelling/applicable to nouns
0 references
general distro is cool but unsure about leveraging binary yes/no votes as a way to scale prop compensation
0 references
not enough demand for nouns OTC atm, sudoswap works great and I anticipate anyone in the near future looking to buy OTC will already be connecting with the community on twitter or discord
0 references
while not specifically labeled gambling it feels close enough that I imagine that being a turn off for voters, also a large ask to build a nouns white label branded version of something that appears to already be getting built -- may need to come back with a smaller/more specific ask that really entices the nouns community
0 references
i support the NNS initiative and feel we should compensate for the work up until this point, but I would like to see a bigger focus on proliferation/marketing plans for NNS as opposed to integrations and updating website
0 references
core issue is talented builders with nouns on their radar, but this prop is targeting people new to the ecosystem? I also dont think the process to ask for money is difficult without connections to the ecosystem -- if an idea/prop is truly compelling it will get the attention of the DAO (ex: salvino lux glasses) not very scalable, we cant afford to pay more and more people $6400 USD/month just to think about nouns part time -- and if we are going to start paying select people to think about nouns, should we be paying new builders to force them to care about nouns vs proven and passionate community members? should gami or i be getting paid to think about future nouns props? appreciate the focus on transparency, but with this being yet another discord in the nouns ecosystem it is a tough ask to join another server just to keep up to date with a single proposal
0 references
appreciate the creativity Sam has injected into the space and look forward to what he and/or Jason do next
0 references
excited to see these come to life but i do not support committing a noun upon delivery of glasses. DAO should evaluate the proposal as a whole after everything has been executed to determine if a noun is justified
0 references
