Proposal 57 (Q1913)
From Nouns Dev
A Nouns proposal.
Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
---|---|---|---|
English | Proposal 57 |
A Nouns proposal. |
Statements
57
0 references
48
0 references
8
0 references
Salvinoarmati
0 references
14 April 2022
0 references
Bring luxury Noun sunglasses to market
0 references
27
0 references
you guys need to vote for this so it doesnt time out
0 references
Im voting FOR prop 57 because in the current world where nouns lacks a mechanism (or any type of process) to compensate for success of proposals (note we fund mostly costs) it makes rational sense for the proposer to include what they want upon success. Naturally its a contentious and painful topic to discuss. Before seeing what the project delivers, how are we to know what the success reward should be? People are mostly arguing that 1 noun is a lot, but it can also be much too little. Ultimately, the correct success reward is infinitely harder to decide upon before the fact and can lead to much wasted heartburn each time. This is why I’d advocate for us to put into place something like [Retroactive Impact Rewards - Nouns](https://discourse.nouns.wtf/t/retroactive-impact-rewards/884) to establish trust with proposers that we will reward success fairly and generously such that we can move the reward discussion moment to AFTER the project is delivered rather than before. In lack of such process and trust in the current state, I do not see it as bad faith or form that a proposer asks for what they want upon success as part of their funding proposal ask. I’ll leave the ambiguity of “successful delivery” which is the 1 noun delivery criteria outside of this discussion. I’m imaging there’s some judgement by the DAO to make when the time comes and should be additional incentive alignment for the proposer to actually deliver something clearly successful in order to earn the noun without debate.
0 references
In general Nouncil was supportive of this proposal. But, for some Nouncillors, the extra Noun felt like too big an ask. This kind of reward would make more sense as a retroactive prize provided after the project is wildly successful.
0 references
14 April 2022
0 references
For the Proposal for the 115 ETH, but the addition of the Noun compensation is different than what was proposed before this got on chain (doc still reflects this) and is a major change. That type of major change should be documented, discussed and socialized before the vote goes on-chain.
0 references
I support the ETH requested, but believe that proposals should be solely comprised of state changes. If a Noun is being granted, it should be transferred by this proposal. If a Noun is deemed a worthy retroactive reward, that decision should be made at the appropriate time, not within the context of the initial proposal.
0 references
in favor of the 115 ETH, but echo the sentiments that the inclusion of a noun deviates from what was originally discussed/proposed.
0 references
excited to see these come to life but i do not support committing a noun upon delivery of glasses. DAO should evaluate the proposal as a whole after everything has been executed to determine if a noun is justified
0 references
115
0 references
16
0 references
115
0 references
The proposal is to fund the launch of a luxury sunglass initiative by salvinoarmati, which will be released as an NFT collection of limited-edition glasses. E ach NFT can be used once to redeem a physical pair of sunglasses. The total supply will be 6969 units, with ~7.2% reserved for the NounsDAO Treasury.
0 references
2
0 references
<@!895344114663575582> when is your wedding? The pricing on the glasses is not as cheap as throwaway stuff but I’d you are doing later ths June maybe we can work out something for you and your guests to have a worlds first Nounish wedding? The pieces are a great keepsake and maybe you can get a local printer to do a special insert?
Arod's wedding is in the middle of August.
0 references
<@!939225061305507910> will you be asking dao for more funding to do a larger run? Idea of anticipated costs?
SalvinoArmati#3839: <@827708794841727076> yes, we will. I'm actually working out the costs right now and drafting the proposal--The question about asking the DAO for more funding to do a larger run and the idea of anticipated costs was answered by SalvinoArmati. They mentioned that they are working on the costs and drafting a proposal for it.
0 references
alternatively could allowlist a handful to nouncil, shark, nounpunks, etc? Just an option..
0 references
Are the nounsdao glasses nfts in the treasury? Do we need to pass a proposal to redeem them? Lots people could use them in their media (esports, TNS, Brazil etc) <@939225061305507910>
Yes, the NounsDAO glasses NFTs are in the treasury. A proposal will be put on chain to extract the allocation from the treasury and distribute them to each community treasury for granular distribution.
0 references
Are you still interested in a NounsVision provided allocation? Only asking since we are still keen to help you mint out by taking advantage of the ZORA Finder’s Fee — great affiliate marketing opportunity / win-win I think.
Yes, SalvinoArmati#3839 is still interested in a NounsVision provided allocation. They have contacted Zora to set it up and are waiting to hear back.
0 references
Do you think these look nounish? Honestly if i saw that in the wild i would not have thought they are affiliated with nouns at all 😅
0 references
gm i'm looking for a GLB file of the nouns glasses for the DCL fashion week, <@!939225061305507910> do you have it by any chance? I was thinking about this model or classic Red
0 references
Gm. Not sure if it's the right place to ask. But does someone know if there is a place where(Brazil or Miami) I can buy or ask to build nouns glasses? *Not in the best quality once I want to give it to my guests at my wedding*
There isn't a specific place mentioned in Brazil or Miami where you can buy or ask to build Nouns glasses. However, Bigshot Klim#1853 suggested that they might be able to work out something for you and your guests if your wedding is later in June. They mentioned that the glasses they are making are reasonably priced and could potentially offer a heavy discount in exchange for photos to share in the press. The glasses are produced in China but shipped out of the US.
0 references
hello fren. may I also get those files too, please? intention is to use the model as part of a special Nouns-themed pill NFT being airdropped to Nouns holders. 🙂
0 references
hey <@!895344114663575582> please stay tuned as we may be able to split the cost or something to help make this work. I think that if we can get some photos and maybe some video that we can use to help show the joy and fun of the NOUNs it may be a great trade and benefit for the Noun brand and for your special day. Where would this be shipped and are there any restrictions /customs reqs in Brazil? I know that sendign things to Korea and Greece has been a challenge <@!372465201808670721>
0 references
Hey <@939225061305507910> and <@940411900087398451> would it be possible to send me the launch video so I could add it to today's edition of Nouns News?
0 references
Hey <@!939225061305507910>, any chance you've considered a proposal for sponsoring RuPaul to wear your luxury glasses on Drag Race?
There hasn't been an official proposal for sponsoring RuPaul to wear the luxury glasses on Drag Race, but the idea was discussed and considered interesting. Bigshot Klim mentioned having a connection with their licensing team in the past.
0 references
heya <@939225061305507910>, any plans for selling Nouns Vision outside of the nouniverse? would love to see if <@400168997779275778> has any tips on using ZORA Finder's Fee to help promote the NFT editions!
0 references
Hey Salvino! Sent a fr to check if you or Signora would be keen to be on Nouns News? Cheers!
0 references
Hi, will it be possible to include Nounsinsg? Would only need 1 allocation of Nouns Vision. <@708131862731554917>
0 references
ooc, are the shots from this photo shoot accessible somewhere and available under the cc0 license?
0 references
The DAO holds 250 of these NFTs? Can we send 10% of that to NOC cc <@!708131862731554917> to award to community members based on merits ?
0 references
Would be huge! Do you guys need some Nouns Coffee mugs / coffee, etc? Would love to fuel the team in any way possible. cc: <@270147458737242112>
0 references
would love to mint (several?) of these - any chance I can get into the premint <@939225061305507910>? see my twitter for nounish-ness, hold lots of extensions... tysm! address pxlmnml.eth/0x298b25385E67B471faa64CB1CA17F31684016629
Yes, you can mint Nouns Vision sunglasses now as they are open to public minting. Visit https://nounsvision.com/ to mint them.
0 references
you sure using delegated address is best? Not sure I’m resolved to gift nouncil my discos just yet
0 references