0x0b3cf56e7df3bb3fb7201ffcd96d279b05ddd2e3 (Q333)
From Nouns Dev
Individual
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | 0x0b3cf56e7df3bb3fb7201ffcd96d279b05ddd2e3 |
Individual |
Statements
- ethOS team is nounish af. - Nouns is the best version of itself when its funding much needed public goods (and accrues good will from crypto community when it does) - reasonable ask, very bold mission - this team ships
0 references
This was a task that was available to do for over a year, and yet no one did it. I personally would have preferred to go with less than 1Ξ. But, I like the originality and the precedent this sets. Do a bit of work, ask for a small payment. More people should do it, and the DAO should continue incentivizing it by voting yes.
0 references
Resounding Yes. Incredible trailer, perfectly reasonable ask, nounish af
0 references
just catching up on this, and this this is such an epic prop. I absolutely love everything about this.
0 references
Both the newsletter and the accountability doc create a ton of value for the DAO. Think its important for this work to continue (along with all the other things that Maty does to make sure things run smoothly).
0 references
This is one of the highest leverage props being worked on right now. Yes, the ETH outlay *is* high for us, but sincerely believe this idea is a bet worth making and this team is the one to bet on to do it. The success case: This product spawns thousands of *high-quality* nounish DAOs. Each success will further cement nouns as the OG, which is recognized for inventing a new form factor for collective action. The failure case: we spend ~15 days of treasury sales Zora is making a huge bet on Nouns — and I can’t tell you how thrilled I am to see such a high-caliber team bet on nouns the way they have. Resounding yes
0 references
obvious yes Also, the only way to talk in the discord now is via proposal votes. Happy Halloween nouners ⌐◨-◨
0 references
A discretionary pool of capital that we can use to fund things quickly has been extremely valuable for the DAO — after looking through the notion doc I think 22 has done a great job curating projects so far. Also agree with the general sentiment that getting more people involved (especially since ETH outlays have become larger). But I think this is something that can be worked on during this round 🙂
0 references
reasonable ask, but unfortunately this doesnt scream nounish for me 🥹
0 references
Didn’t read the prop tbh. Proxied my sense-making to everyone else on this one
0 references
Dear Gami, my brother in christ. Youve done an incredible job with Gnars so far which is why I really deliberated on this one for so long. Unfortunately, I dont think this proposal (as it stands today) is ready to be passed given the ask. My primary reason is that gnars should go into much more detail into the following two questions: 1. What did Gnars do with the previous proposal? 2. What does Gnars *plan* to do with the funding moving forward? Re: Question 1 — I know youve done some really awesome things like sponsor the skater that won the championship! and other awesome things which probably resulted in lots of impressions for ⌐◨-◨ — but your prop doesnt go into these details 🥹 More generally, i sincerely think its important for nouns to create a culture where proposers provide sufficient context *on-chain*. It is especially important in a community where new members join every single day, so that each new member can make the best possible decision with sufficient context. To summarize, Id prefer to see this back on-chain with more detail and broken up into 2 stages.
0 references
Im not convinced that its a good idea to create an intermediary consulting team that tries to increase the quality of props. In theory, there should be sufficient incentive for the proposers to already do that given the fact that they receive grant funding at the end. Gathering attention, community buy-in, writing a great proposal should all be a part of the proof-of-work required to get a prop passed. Having said that, Im all for making it easier to communicate your prop (by adding functionality to clients etc.)
0 references
