Proposal 269 (Q138)
From Nouns Dev
A Nouns proposal.
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | Proposal 269 |
A Nouns proposal. |
Statements
135
0 references
Gnarly EP
0 references
269
0 references
101
0 references
13 April 2023
0 references
Back yourself - Find your people, know your place, do your thing.
0 references
Over time I expect droposals will have increased competition for the provenance of minting through Nouns DAO and we will naturally fine tune our instincts about details like the % revenue returned. In the short term, this is entertaining. The songs are fun and deploying this costs next to nothing. Im voting for. If this doesnt pass I think it makes sense for Gnars to deploy this themselves.
0 references
These tracks meet the quality standards for Nounish Media, and I appreciate them. Nounish Media often struggles to expand its audience beyond our usual viewership, resulting in low view counts for even the most exceptional videos. These tracks have the potential to reach a wider audience outside of our usual demographic, which is why I think the no-cost experiment to break out of our bubble with these tracks is an excellent idea. Additionally they are enjoyable, slightly absurd and fun.
0 references
Had the same internal debate as Noun40, and decided the same way. Gnars is Nounish.
0 references
Excerpt from my newsletter (https://t.co/BFd43TBghs) : This is a great initiative. It is a sustainable way to support and encourage more nounish content creators.
0 references
Lil Bubble is nounish af. Love this prop and his music. ⌐◨-◨
0 references
22
had a moment of wondering if it’s not more appropriate for this to be a gnars mint than a nouns mint esp given the mint proceeds split much favors gnars, but decided to err on the side of voting yes given gnars is a nounish subculture that I wholeheartedly love and want to celebrate the first EP from this special place.
0 references
Theres an interesting conversation to be had about the concept of nounish media, which I think is still lacking in both meaning and purpose. That being said, one thing thats clear to me is the fact that where a centralized brand has serious limitations in what it can create, a headless brand has the advantage of endorsing a diverse variety of creations made by various individuals and groups, and simply observing which ones gain the most traction. Since this EP doesnt require funding, but only seeks a co-sign in the form of a droposal, I believe its worth supporting.
0 references
**FOR - 34 VOTES** **Benbodhi** | *🎼🎶🎵🎹🎸🥁🎤🤘* **dot** | *🤘* **Sasquatch** | *:pepe_jam:* **AGAINST - 5 VOTES**
0 references
Primary concern here is I dont see a reason why this should be a Nouns droposal and not a Gnars droposal. But, even if there is a justifiable reason for it to be a Nouns droposal that Im just not seeing, 10% to me seems like too low of a percentage of funds to flow back to Nouns (I know theres not a lot of clarity/consensus on what makes sense here for droposals, but thats just my personal opinion).
0 references
29
I largely agree with Wilson. Would rather set a precedent that a much larger percentage of droposal revenue should go Nouns, even if it means funding the work ourselves.
0 references
In my vote for prop 260, I said > Droposals are a new pattern that were still figuring out, but my feeling is they should mainly be used for ratifying/approving of works that were funded by the DAO. They also generally involve revenue back to the DAO, which does not seem to be the case here. So for these reasons, I am voting against. This again is a case of work that was not commissioned/paid for by Nouns DAO, but rather Gnars DAO and 40% of the revenue here is going back to Gnars DAO. This makes sense to me, and I see no reason for Nouns DAO to be involved. If we were to get involved in this way, I think the DAOs droposal commission should be MUCH higher than 10%. I like the music and wish the project well!
0 references
78
0 references
Lil bubble
0 references
13 April 2023
0 references
57
0 references
Gnarly EP is a three-track release by recording artist Lil Bubble, commissioned by Gnars DAO. The music and cover art are officially released under CC0. Lil Bubble, a Web3-native character, has been creating satirical songs and music videos since 2019, amassing over 10 million views.
0 references
3
0 references
0
0 references
Aren't submissions refundable as votes are?
Submissions are not refundable as votes are.
0 references
Are you going to have Gnars handle the droposal or resubmit with adjusted percentages to Nouns?
They will discuss with the involved parties and consider resubmitting the proposal with adjusted percentages.
0 references
I have a question and this isnt in relation to this prop in particular, but many props in general. --Members of DAO buy tokens-> DOA funds Projects -> in celebration members of DAO are end distribution of product at more cost. --This seems to be the current model, and I'm not sure it sits well or is proper. --If we are talking about WHY buy tokens well,,, answer is always utility. where have ANY token holders been provided with Utility along this path? -Any mint price above some type of .0042-.0069 (for teh culture -> and acknowledging a JOB WELL DONE) seems to be extractionary. not only that I think the This is Nouns .. while it gathered a lot of funding wasnt successful in explaining nouns to the world. many walked away from that mint with a bad taste. (DYOR, yes... but still) --I also understand that this is a new model . early . will tokens have use case later... etc etc .... but just some thoughts I have been thinking. wanted to get down.
The current model you mentioned involves DAO members buying tokens, funding projects, and then being part of the end distribution of the product at an additional cost. You questioned the utility provided to token holders along this path. In the case of the Gnarly EP drop, the singles are being sold at around $10 each, and if you collect all three, you get the EP for free. As for explicit utility, they function as voting tokens on `thatsgnar.ly`. The .0042-.0069 range is considered a reasonable ask when selling an OE collectible. It's important to manage expectations and avoid vague promises of utility that can cause speculation.
0 references
my dip thots on this defeat! https://twitter.com/davinoyesigye/status/1650371892086202370?s=20--tbh, going to have to chat w/ <@468538672577249301> because this was un-expected 😜 , but we respect all voters choices just wish we had a voteWithReason on <@411952680244740096> vote! re-submitting with better percentages is a no brainer! personally want to appreciate all Nouners and Noun Holders for taking time to read this proposal and share their opinions on how we can further develop and curate all future nounish droposals by our dear nouns.eth treasury!--NOTE: given gnars was funded to be the redbull of web3 - we are going to keep funding this experiment, redbull has a music label that prints them some good revenue! we can easily achieve this with gnarsDAO, because there is no extreme sports event that doesn't have music playing as the shredders kick it.. the symbiotic relationship between music and extreme sports is similar to the love-hate relationship nouns has with gnarsDAO..--QUESTION: what's a good nounsDAO revenue (%) percentage for music NFTs dropped by NounsDAO? for this to make sense for NounsDAO <@393902285396377612> <@534758763983274014> 🙏
A good NounsDAO revenue percentage for music NFTs dropped by NounsDAO has not been specified in the conversation.
0 references
This Week:-1. Upcoming Daily Gnar O'clock event is discussed.-2. A Community Call on Go Skate Day is mentioned.-3. Potential artist series of skateboards through GNars is discussed.-4. The auction, Gnarupdate, and Old Skaters Tricks Challenge are mentioned.-5. Updates on merch production are shared.-6. The upcoming 1-year TNS anniversary show is discussed.
20 June 2023
0 references
This week:-1. Participants discuss working on a subgraph and a settlement tracker.-2. They prioritize the nouns gnars switch for easier debugging.-3. Mention of testing the service worker and creating a toggle between gnars and nouns.-4. Discussion of building locally and addressing issues with Stoken and Gnars.fun.-5. Consideration of adding Roko Bot to the chat.-6. The group discusses games built by the community.
20 June 2023
0 references
This week:-1. The chat focuses on automating collabs and daily drops.-2. Rocketman mentions sending something tomorrow and working on automatic payouts for collab drops.-3. 3rd inquires about receiving $20 after a drop.-4. Mamaxa seeks help hosting daily Twitter spaces.-5. Marini discusses Surfguru partnering with initiatives, minting content, and empowering social initiatives through surf content.
20 June 2023
0 references
This week:-1. Anderson_Crypt0 offers to teach 10 people how to earn $30k within 72 hours.-2. Users celebrate Go Skate Day and discuss a movie premiere.-3. A weekly community call is about to start.-4. Users discuss a browser extension, its features, and a recent airdrop with gas fees.-5. A CS:GO 2 BETA giveaway is announced with 1,000,000 copies available.-6. Various topics are discussed, including music, auctions, and upcoming events.-7. A Noun Movie Pilot Premiere takes place in TNS Discord.-8. Users discuss a Blackrock BTC ETF and a proposal on Nouns Discord.
27 June 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. Users share information about an official CS:GO 2 BETA giveaway by VALVE with 1,000,000 copies available.-2. Users are encouraged to click the provided link to participate in the giveaway.-3. Ilustradora interacts with Gnarly Bot, successfully guessing a number in 2 attempts and winning 615.
27 June 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. Akva praises the team's work and expresses excitement for the project.-2. Mconst discusses differences between the gnars and foodnouns subgraphs, noting the absence of `settlementCount` and `totalSettlementFee` in the gnars subgraph.-3. The team considers working on a standalone version and potential improvements.-4. Vlad suggests implementing a Discord command, adding a contribution guide, and app links.-5. Volky mentions the subgraph not being set up for a local environment.
27 June 2023
0 references
This week:-1. Akva greets the group and Rickyday shares a new music release for the surf and skate community.-2. Members congratulate and support Nissin's new platform and Pereirap's photography.-3. A failed attempt at a joint attack in a game is discussed.-4. International Skate Day is celebrated with Naw Miranda's artistic work.-5. The group talks about a browser extension and challenges of introducing Gnars to YouTubers.-6. Members wish each other a good morning and a great week ahead.
27 June 2023
0 references
This week:-1. Luizha and a colleague plan to participate in a live event about Gnars for the Surfguru and NXF Bodyboard communities.-2. Luizha proposes maintaining and growing revenue from NFT sales through brand awareness and benefits for Gnars holders, exploring new revenue sources, and considering athlete sponsorships.-3. Dabel seeks assistance in creating a page on the Nouns website.-4. Vlad and Akva discuss the difference between travel grants and sponsorships.-5. Davinoyesi suggests creating a Gnars Sales Team and discusses plans for selling GnarSauce and Gnars streetwear.
4 July 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. Luizha thanks participants and shares a link to a live event on Instagram with Surfguru and NXF Bodyboard.-2. Jasper experiences issues with his account and Dell notebook.-3. Eze shares a photo by Renato Galvão and encourages likes and comments.-4. Break encourages voting on a proposal.-5. Luizha proposes a travel grant to Indonesia to create content for gnars and asks for votes.-6. Rickyday shares videos of his experiences working on a sailboat.-7. Nissin shares a video of a line he recorded at a new plaza.-8. Rickyday shares a new song for the surf and skate family.
4 July 2023
0 references
This week:-1. Devansh, the Marketing Lead for Mercle, introduces himself and shares his gaming skills.-2. Pikel, handling Motion and Visual design, expresses his excitement about the project and his recent interest in skateboarding.-3. Sager from Portland, OR, shares his experience with longboarding.-4. Jacen from Cyprus expresses his desire to contribute as a moderator, fostering positive relationships and encouraging productive conversations.-5. Pharrá, an architect from Rio de Janeiro, introduces herself and mentions her creation, the Opstacle.-6. Davide from Mexico shares his work in mayaspirits nft and his intention to onboard a talented skater.-7. Marcelo Cardozo from Paraguay introduces himself as a visual artist and skater who runs a cultural space.-8. Peter, a lens-based artist from Bangkok, shares his experience as the co-founder of Europe's first crossover Skate- and Snowboard magazine.
4 July 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. Rickyday announces the addition of a Sailing category on Thatsgnarly and shares new videos of his sailing experiences.-2. Eze shares a post about a work by Renato Galvão in Brazil.-3. Davinoyesi discusses payment issues related to the community's activities.-4. Marini and 3rd discuss issues with receiving NFT gnars and payments for drops.-5. Overhau is looking for Nounish films on YouTube.-6. Rocketman comments on an expired prop related to NFTs.-7. Joaoparmagn shares about a post he made on Hive about surfguruDAO and a championship.-8. Rickyday ends with a message for the shredding community.
4 July 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. There's a discussion about a Villa Nouns contest on Twitter, with the winner receiving a free summer vacation in Italy.-2. Suggestions are made to prevent proposal spam in the channel, including directing it to a specific channel or creating a temporary forum room.-3. Participants discuss voting and participation in various projects and contests, and one participant expresses interest in connecting with a property owner in Bali for future projects.-4. A daily event called Gnar O'clock at The Noun Square is discussed, along with Gnars Health insurance.-5. Rickyday announces a successful post about a gnars sponsorship, leading to increased interest in the culture.-6. Geff mentions a crypto payment method for ordering a bottle, with the first 69 orders being free.-7. There's a giveaway for a 5-day stay at Villa Nouns.-8. The chat concludes with a discussion about the friction of gas costs of onchain governance and the potential for funding infinite prop houses and pod/multisigs.
11 July 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. The group discussed a recent collaboration event in their city, sharing photos and videos.-2. A skater named Gal performed a backside Smith grind at the event.-3. The group discussed their partnership with the Gnars community.-4. Vlad offered to pay 0.01 ETH for English subtitles for a video.-5. The group encouraged each other to vote and support their community.-6. A new member, deathcat2, joined the Gnars community and made his first post.-7. The group mentioned a live Instagram event with Surfguru and NXF Bodyboard to discuss Gnars and answer community questions.
11 July 2023
0 references
This Week:-1. Various introductions are made, including Jay3584, Davinoyesi, Marcello Grosso, Deathcat2, Kokoh Pambudi, Devhai, and Pikel1.-2. Marini announces that Greek people can now add a Greece role and chat in it, which 0xsat welcomes.-3. Marcello Grosso introduces himself as a Brazilian Punk Rock singer, skater, and PhD in International Politics.-4. Deathcat introduces himself as the Cat from Hell, whose owner is a Doom Skater.-5. Kokoh Pambudi, a designer from Bali, Indonesia, shares a link to his Instagram filter and expresses openness for collaboration.-6. Devhai, the Marketing Lead at Mercle, jokes about his proficiency in Tony Hawk's games but lack of knowledge in staking.-7. Pikel1, also from Mercle, shares his interest in the project and his recent experience learning how to skate.-8. Marini suggests creating a Greece role and global room, and Knowho agrees to let Marini know when there are enough people for this.
11 July 2023
0 references
Anderson_Crypt0 offers to teach 10 people how to earn $30k within 72 hours, while others wish a happy skateboarding day. A movie premiere is announced, and a weekly community call is about to start. Users discuss a browser extension and its features, as well as a recent airdrop and gas fees.
22 June 2023
0 references
The chatlog is a discussion about a Villa Nouns contest on Twitter, where the winner gets a free summer vacation in Italy. The participants are encouraged to share the initiative. There's also a discussion about preventing the channel from being filled with proposal spam, with suggestions to direct it to a specific channel or create a temporary forum room. Some participants share their proposals and others discuss voting and participation in various projects and contests. One participant mentions wanting to connect with the owner of a certain property in Bali for future projects.
7 July 2023
0 references
This Month:-1. Anderson_Crypt0 offers to teach 10 people how to earn $30k within 72 hours, sparking interest in the community.-2. A CS:GO 2 BETA giveaway is announced with 1,000,000 copies available, creating excitement among the users.-3. The Noun Movie Pilot Premiere takes place in TNS Discord, generating discussions and engagement.-4. Users discuss a Blackrock BTC ETF and a proposal on Nouns Discord, indicating a keen interest in financial matters.-5. The upcoming Daily Gnar O'clock event and a Community Call on Go Skate Day are discussed, showing the community's involvement in events.-6. Potential artist series of skateboards through GNars is discussed, indicating a creative direction for the community.-7. Updates on merch production are shared, showing progress in community projects.-8. The upcoming 1-year TNS anniversary show is discussed, reflecting on the community's growth and achievements.-9. Luizha requests votes for a travel grant proposal to Indonesia, showing the community's support for individual projects.-10. Davinoyesi promotes Daily Drop Shows and Gnars Jam Session, indicating ongoing community activities.-11. Pha introduces herself as the architect who created the Opstacle in Rio
1 July 2023
0 references
This Month:-1. An official CS:GO 2 BETA giveaway by VALVE was announced, with 1,000,000 copies available for the community.-2. Vlad requested permissions to manage messages in a particular room, highlighting the need to delete messages from scammers.-3. 『NF』DENOM announced a new NFT project called 3D NFT play2earn Web3 Game and is looking for moderators and beta testers.
1 July 2023
0 references
This Month:-1. Mconst discusses differences between the gnars and foodnouns subgraphs, noting the absence of `settlementCount` and `totalSettlementFee` in the gnars subgraph.-2. The team considers working on a standalone version and potential improvements, including implementing a Discord command, adding a contribution guide, and app links.-3. Participants discuss working on a subgraph and a settlement tracker, prioritizing the nouns gnars switch for easier debugging, and testing the service worker.-4. There is a discussion about building locally and addressing issues with Stoken and Gnars.fun, as well as the possibility of adding Roko Bot to the chat.-5. 0xig agrees to embed another service for serving snippets, as long as they don't have to serve it themselves, and suggests pasting in a discord embed code snippet of the auctions channel on the site.-6. Vlad suggests a temporary trollbox or embedding telegram and mattrix to serve discord, and asks if it's possible to create a gnars agora and if they can add a roko bot.-7. 0xig announces that they've found and fixed an issue with snapshot and are now testing it, and proposes to fund an athlete pod for onboarding
1 July 2023
0 references
This Month:-1. Members congratulate and support Nissin's new platform and Pereirap's photography.-2. The group talks about a browser extension and challenges of introducing Gnars to YouTubers.-3. Break voted on a proposal and encouraged others to support it.-4. Luizha has a proposal on snapshot for a travel grant to Indonesia to produce content for gnars and asked for votes.-5. Vlad mentioned that the architect responsible for the original design of the first OPSTACLE posted on thatsgnarly for the first time.-6. Rickyday shared videos of his experiences working on a sailboat on thatsgnarly.-7. Marini announced the launch of SurfguruDAO in partnership with Surfguru, where they will post surf content and support socio-environmental initiatives.-8. Marini mentioned they are trying to gather all media to make a documentary about NFT Brazil.-9. Bruno Mombaque, a skateboarder, joined the community.
1 July 2023
0 references
This Month:-1. Marini and Akva discuss the potential use of a prop house for a project, gaining support from the community.-2. 0xig proposes funding a community/media pod to manage an Instagram account for the project, suggesting that this could increase engagement.-3. Davinoyesi highlights the need for a dedicated person to conduct daily Instagram live drops, indicating a move towards more interactive content.-4. 0xig offers to provide access to Tweetdeck for Twitter, emphasizing the importance of multi-platform engagement.-5. Rickyday.eth and Marini express their support for these social media initiatives, indicating a positive community response.
1 July 2023
0 references
