(Q1844)

**Nouncil Vote:** 7 Yes, 46 No, 1 Abstain 6 Nouncillors abstained from the decision **NO WINS** --- **Vote Reasons & Discussion** --- **Josep** | *I don’t think it’s necessary to pay 29ETH to integrate Nouns into a service like this. The should ask for less ETH* **Brook** | *lessons from dissolution of Nouns discord and failure of prop 200:* *- no re-skins; encourage native solutions to native problems are encouraged* *- established forms of communication such as Twitter, Farcaster, and DIscord suffice. hence voters dont see a reason to invest in another one. atleast for now* **.ZllW ⌐◨-◨** | *Dont really see a demand for this tool* **pemburux** | *Agreed you all, with 29 ETH for the current state we can promote Nouns even more* **byhardy** | *Cool concept, not sure it would get used or if there is a fit here. Dont love proposals that dont support wider Nounish ecosystem of non-holders. To this end, the prop feels a bit tone deaf. The prop does not even mention delegates, but the prop is from a delegate themselves?* *I do think both skiff and this prop are on the right track, but they should adapt to accomodate other builders in the Nouns ecosystem (and delegates) who dont own a Noun yet.* **andreitr** | *Voting against this because it does not benefit the broader Nounish community nor does it help proliferate the Noun meme.* **RyanMac ⌐◨-◨** | *great resource for nounders to always stay connected & up to date on the ecosystem* **0xDariush** | *targeting only nouns holders is not nounish enough.* *We have 340 holders atm and at this early stage even if 30% of them gonna use it its going to be like a small gathering.* **BENJAMIN LATSKO ⌐◧-◧** | *cute but no. nouners dont even buy nouns tshirts* **Benbodhi** | *Id like to see this as a nouniverse platform rather than just nouners, I think thered be a larger userbase and it would be more valuable then.* **Mach** | *not a fan of the presented concept. Maybe a better proof of concept could sway me in future, but the project is potentially dead on arrival. Nouns risks spreading itself too thin over hundreds of communities, websites, and forums to continue funding more* **Mindtoasted** | *I want to vote no on this, why? indeed there are many useful features in this proposal, do not forget to also see how punksclub runs. I think if it can only be used by nouners thats great, but it could be eve