Proposal 9 (Q2412)
From Nouns Dev
Proposal Type
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | Proposal 9 |
Proposal Type |
Statements
23
0 references
0
0 references
Nouns Bidder POAP
0 references
5
0 references
9
0 references
29 September 2021
0 references
29 September 2021
0 references
1
0 references
4
0 references
20
0 references
40
0 references
0
0 references
Brkfstsndwch, david horvath, bored ux
0 references
The proposal is to fund the Nouns Bidder POAP Project, which aims to create a microsite where people who have bid on or settled a Noun can claim a free POAP (Proof Of Attendanc e Protocol). This project is designed to encourage participation in the Nouns community. The team will use etherscan.io data and the poap.
0 references
<@362737590430072862> How would I get the Prop Builder role?
SerNoadz, you should now have the Prop Builder role as devcarrot mentioned, Should be good to go.
0 references
Good point and interesting to see the results. I feel like the last 2 weeks have had fewer small bids (gas price? attention cycling in/out?)
0 references
Hello all. I was just looking through DAO proposals on the nouns website, and see a POAP project was approved... Will this include bidders/winners in the testnet auctions?
The POAP project that was approved is different from the testnet auctions. It is for runners up in the Noun auctions and will not include bidders/winners in the testnet auctions.
0 references
Here’s what we’re proposing to solve the awareness and trigger problem.--Primary Solution: Airdropping the POAP eliminates the risk that the user is qualified and unknowingly misses the opportunity to claim the POAP.--Secondary Solution: Create a banner or content block on nouns.wtf to advertise the POAP to the top 5 losing bids to improve awareness. Possibly creating a bot to automatically tag top losing bidders on twitter/discord to create a trigger.--—--Useful Feedback: Are these viable solutions that best represent the Nouns community and ecosystem?--Are there any objections to airdropping POAPs? Airdrops have become somewhat controversial, but solve the awareness and trigger problem I’ve described.--I know this is very long-winded but we didn’t want to make a decision without inviting input. --Obviously, once we make a decision here, it will heavily inform how the UX of the POAP site is designed.
0 references
How will the demo be conducted?
The demo will be conducted using general-voice and screensharing on Discord. The team will run through the site's flow live with whoever is on the call.
0 references
in the 'Trigger' section, could you just have both solutions? Airdrop for top 5 bids, otherwise notify -> claim?
Yes, if you bid on a Noun and don't win, your ETH will be returned to you. The process of returning the ETH is called settling. However, the conversation does not provide specific information on when the ETH will be reverted.
0 references
Question: if you bid on a noun and don’t win, does your ETH revert to you? If so, when? Thanks
Yes, if you bid on a noun and don't win, your ETH reverts to you pretty immediately.
0 references
**TEAM UPDATE 10.14**--**Nounish Beings R1 Updates**--- David has taken a first pass at a large run of unique options for Nounish Beings. You can view those attached below. We would love your feedback, notes, any initial thoughts you have. So share away!-- With those notes, David will then work on adjusting the Nounish Beings to fit within the constraints of the POAP system's file requirements.--**Bidder User Journey**-**Trigger**-The Trigger function in the user journey is where we have a few questions we'd like to propose to the Nouns Community in order to gather a preferred consensus. There are two ways to go about the trigger/receiving process with the end result of holding the Bidder POAP. View those below:- -1. You can use the microsite to claim your own POAP and go through the poap.xyz ecosystem through our microsite. - - 2. We can claim the POAP for the Bidder Winners and have the POAP sent to them within the poap.xyz ecosystem. If we were to go this route, we would end up creating a microsite that is more of a playground for people to explore what this POAP and the Nounish Beings are all about. Think, more information on Nouns, David, the proliferation of the community, fun features to explore different POAPs etc. - -Beyond those two options for the trigger/receipt function, we have a larger question for the Nouns Community. Read below:--- In order to bring awareness to this microsite and the ability to claim, for free a Nouns Bidder POAP, would the DAO be open to allowing the addition of a link within the main nav or footer that would then send people to our microsite to be able to let bidders know they have this free gift that they get to claim? And also allow people just explore and learn more while waiting for auctions to end, etc.- ----------------------------- - We would love any and all thoughts on the initial question of the trigger as well as thoughts on the proposition of an additional link on the site for the POAP function. - --**Next Steps**-<@!827964581850513408> | Creation of initial moodboard for site style-<@!816727974485164062> | Updates and refinements of the Nounish Beings-<@!620406459913469955> | Come to a consensus on the backend claiming or aridropping function for the POAPs
0 references
Two ways to interpret this:--1. Are you insinuating bids 6 through n can claim? I think there were some strong objections to this during the proposal phase because it would be easy to exploit.--2. Once a POAP is airdropped, would there be a need to claim again? We don’t have plans to allow multiple POAPs to be claimed by one wallet.--Also, the challenge with the current state of Web3 wallets is there isn’t a way to send notifications. The convenience of airdropping bypasses the need to notify.
The question was whether bids 6 through n can claim POAPs and if there would be a need to claim again once a POAP is airdropped. The answers provided in the direct reply are:--1. The initial idea was for the top 10 bidders (top 5 = airdrop, 6-10 = claim), but after revisiting the proposal, it was agreed to restrict it to the top 5 bidders.-2. There wouldn't be a need to claim again if the user is airdropped a POAP.
0 references
Wonderful work! I know there was previous discussion of this so apologies for being late. Once you’re not manually adding poap winners, would it be possible to allow all bidders to get a poap, not just top 5? The reason for this is that it allows anyone to be feel connected to Nouns and get something Noun related. I imagine the top 5 will be 10+ETH bids so only whales will be able to get poaps. Whales are already being rewarded by battling it out and getting a Noun. For non-whales there’s still a barrier to entry with gas prices being high so it still requires a commitment to bid and be poap’ed
0 references
