Proposal 247 (Q120): Difference between revisions

From Nouns Dev
(‎Changed an Item)
(‎Changed an Item)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Sec / rank
Normal rank
 
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Contract / rank
Normal rank
 
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Book / rank
Normal rank
 
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Summary / rank
Normal rank
 
Property / Summary
Summary: Rage Quit (RQ) is a proposed feature for the NounsDAO that allows members to exit the DAO and receive their share of the treasury. The main concern against RQ was that it might make Nouns a security, but the DAO already operates in a grey area regarding SEC regulations.
 
Property / Summary: Summary: Rage Quit (RQ) is a proposed feature for the NounsDAO that allows members to exit the DAO and receive their share of the treasury. The main concern against RQ was that it might make Nouns a security, but the DAO already operates in a grey area regarding SEC regulations. / rank
Normal rank
 
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Sec laws / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Proposal Type
 
Property / Proposal Type: Rage quit contract / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Related Channel
 
Property / Related Channel: The Jungle: Nouns DAO - 248-rage-quit / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Team Size
 
1
Amount1
Unit1
Property / Team Size: 1 / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Proposal Duration in Months
 
0
Amount0
Unit1
Property / Proposal Duration in Months: 0 / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Abstain Count
 
0
Amount0
Unit1
Property / Abstain Count: 0 / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Proposal Budget in ETH
 
3,674
Amount3,674
Unit1
Property / Proposal Budget in ETH: 3,674 / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Summary
 
The text discusses the implementation of a Rage Quit (RQ) option for members of a DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization). The RQ option allows members to leave the DAO an d receive their share of the treasury.
Property / Summary: The text discusses the implementation of a Rage Quit (RQ) option for members of a DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization). The RQ option allows members to leave the DAO an d receive their share of the treasury. / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Question & Answer
 
imo nouns needs a 100% refund policy to so as to wade these cc0 waters without brand damaging litigation. But i would vote for the idea of the DAO getting to vote to refund rage quiters - submit your proposal as to why you want to to exit nouns? + book value ETh request. i don't see why a valid reason why a 27k + ETH DAO cant refund a 25ETH purchase..DAOs shall not turn into prisons! a beg
Property / Question & Answer: imo nouns needs a 100% refund policy to so as to wade these cc0 waters without brand damaging litigation. But i would vote for the idea of the DAO getting to vote to refund rage quiters - submit your proposal as to why you want to to exit nouns? + book value ETh request. i don't see why a valid reason why a 27k + ETH DAO cant refund a 25ETH purchase..DAOs shall not turn into prisons! a beg / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Question & Answer: imo nouns needs a 100% refund policy to so as to wade these cc0 waters without brand damaging litigation. But i would vote for the idea of the DAO getting to vote to refund rage quiters - submit your proposal as to why you want to to exit nouns? + book value ETh request. i don't see why a valid reason why a 27k + ETH DAO cant refund a 25ETH purchase..DAOs shall not turn into prisons! a beg / qualifier
 
Property / Question & Answer: imo nouns needs a 100% refund policy to so as to wade these cc0 waters without brand damaging litigation. But i would vote for the idea of the DAO getting to vote to refund rage quiters - submit your proposal as to why you want to to exit nouns? + book value ETh request. i don't see why a valid reason why a 27k + ETH DAO cant refund a 25ETH purchase..DAOs shall not turn into prisons! a beg / qualifier
 
Answer: There will eventually be a split mechanism, probably some variation of what Verbs is working on. This mechanism may address the concerns about refunds and exiting the DAO.
Property / Question & Answer
 
why are you getting so emotional over this (twitter and discord)? Its a proposal, if it passes it passes, if it doesnt it doesnt.--4156 was raging the other week its an open organization, rather than complaining, people just submit a proposal. Well, guess what, I submitted one and am just getting attacked lmao
Property / Question & Answer: why are you getting so emotional over this (twitter and discord)? Its a proposal, if it passes it passes, if it doesnt it doesnt.--4156 was raging the other week its an open organization, rather than complaining, people just submit a proposal. Well, guess what, I submitted one and am just getting attacked lmao / rank
 
Normal rank
Property / Question & Answer: why are you getting so emotional over this (twitter and discord)? Its a proposal, if it passes it passes, if it doesnt it doesnt.--4156 was raging the other week its an open organization, rather than complaining, people just submit a proposal. Well, guess what, I submitted one and am just getting attacked lmao / qualifier
 
Property / Question & Answer: why are you getting so emotional over this (twitter and discord)? Its a proposal, if it passes it passes, if it doesnt it doesnt.--4156 was raging the other week its an open organization, rather than complaining, people just submit a proposal. Well, guess what, I submitted one and am just getting attacked lmao / qualifier
 
Answer: NounsDAO is a very dear project to many, and proposals that focus on dividing and dismantling what has been built so far would be naturally met with defensive responses. It is encouraged to focus on building and spreading the nounish culture instead. While there is support for the idea of an exit mechanism, the current proposal has been met with strong opposition due to its one-sided nature and potential negative impact on the DAO.

Latest revision as of 15:02, 17 July 2023

A Nouns proposal.
Language Label Description Also known as
English
Proposal 247
A Nouns proposal.

    Statements

    instance of
    Proposal
    0 references
    Status
    CANCELLED
    0 references
    Quorumvotes
    63
    0 references
    Opposer Count
    0
    0 references
    Label
    Rage Quit
    0 references
    Id
    247
    0 references
    Supporter Count
    0
    0 references
    Proposal Type
    Dao
    0 references
    Rage quit
    0 references
    Treasury
    0 references
    Sec laws
    0 references
    Rage quit contract
    0 references
    ExecutionETA
    8 March 2023
    0 references
    Team Name
    Rage quit
    0 references
    Proposal Submission Date
    8 March 2023
    0 references
    Team Size
    1
    0 references
    Abstain Count
    0
    0 references
    Proposal Budget in ETH
    3,674
    0 references
    Summary
    The text discusses the implementation of a Rage Quit (RQ) option for members of a DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization). The RQ option allows members to leave the DAO an d receive their share of the treasury.
    0 references
    Question & Answer
    imo nouns needs a 100% refund policy to so as to wade these cc0 waters without brand damaging litigation. But i would vote for the idea of the DAO getting to vote to refund rage quiters - submit your proposal as to why you want to to exit nouns? + book value ETh request. i don't see why a valid reason why a 27k + ETH DAO cant refund a 25ETH purchase..DAOs shall not turn into prisons! a beg
    Related Channel
    The Jungle: Nouns DAO - 248-rage-quit
    Answer
    There will eventually be a split mechanism, probably some variation of what Verbs is working on. This mechanism may address the concerns about refunds and exiting the DAO.
    0 references
    why are you getting so emotional over this (twitter and discord)? Its a proposal, if it passes it passes, if it doesnt it doesnt.--4156 was raging the other week its an open organization, rather than complaining, people just submit a proposal. Well, guess what, I submitted one and am just getting attacked lmao
    Related Channel
    The Jungle: Nouns DAO - 248-rage-quit
    Answer
    NounsDAO is a very dear project to many, and proposals that focus on dividing and dismantling what has been built so far would be naturally met with defensive responses. It is encouraged to focus on building and spreading the nounish culture instead. While there is support for the idea of an exit mechanism, the current proposal has been met with strong opposition due to its one-sided nature and potential negative impact on the DAO.
    0 references
     
    Retrieved from "https://nounsdev.wikibase.cloud/w/index.php?title=Item:Q120&oldid=9514"